Ninth Circuit To Hear Challenge To Washington’s Background Check Law

AUSTIN JENKINS / NORTHWEST NEWS NETWORK

Listen

A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals will hear a challenge Monday to Washington’s voter-approved background check law for person-to-person gun transfers.

The lawsuit challenges provisions of Initiative 594 which voters overwhelmingly passed in 2014. Specifically, the plaintiffs argue that the background check requirement fails to exempt certain temporary, non-commercial gun transfers that could put law-abiding gun owners at risk of prosecution.

Plaintiffs’ attorney David Edwards offered the example of an unmarried couple who share a pistol.

“They have a single firearm that they keep in their home for self-defense and the concern is that the statute essentially says that they cannot both use that firearm,” Edwards said.

Other scenarios raised by the lawsuit include a person who checks their gun as baggage before flying to Seattle and then retrieves the gun from an airline employee upon arrival, or someone who wants to borrow a gun while visiting from out of state.

In addition to the individuals, the plaintiffs include the Bellevue-based Second Amendment Foundation.

Edwards is appealing a 2015 lower court ruling that found the plaintiffs don’t have standing to sue because they haven’t been prosecuted.

The Alliance for Gun Responsibility, which sponsored Initiative 594, called the lawsuit “unfounded” and said the claims are based on “hypothetical situations.”

“Since the initiative became law, we’ve seen smooth adoption by gun owners and dealers,” the Alliance’s CEO Renee Hopkins said in a statement. “The law is doing exactly what it was intended to do—help keep guns out of dangerous hands.”

According to the Alliance, between December 2014 and April 2017, I-594 prevented 201 private sales of guns.

This year, the Washington Legislature clarified what constitutes a gun transfer under Initiative 594. As a result, some of the plaintiffs—a security firm, a private investigator association and a gun safety school—are dropping out of the lawsuit.

“I’m satisfied,” said Monica Cowles of the Northwest School of Safety, the lead plaintiff in the case. Cowles trains women in the safe handling of guns. Before the change, in the law she was concerned that she and her clients would run afoul of the law by taking turns handling different guns during class.

According to the Washington Attorney General’s office, which will defend the law in court, only two people have faced prosecution under Initiative 594. One is charged with illegally transferring a gun that was later used in a murder. The other is accused of stealing a gun and then exchanging it for drugs.

“Nothing about these two prosecutions creates for Plaintiffs a genuine threat of imminent prosecution,’” Deputy Solicitor General Jeffrey Even wrote in a court filing.

Copyright 2017 Northwest News Network. To see more, visit Northwest News Network.

Related Stories:

Adam Beach durante el Warner Bros. The Big Picture 2016 en el CinemaCon el martes 12 de abril de 2016, en Las Vegas. (Crédito: Richard Shotwell/Invision for Warner Bros./AP Images).

Galardonado actor Adam Beach visita Toppenish

Noviembre es el Mes de la Herencia Nativa Americana. En el centro de Washington, diferentes actos celebran a estas comunidades. El viernes 22 de noviembre, Heritage University recibirá en Toppenish al galardonado actor Adam Beach.

Read More »
Adam Beach during the world premiere of "Suicide Squad" at the Beacon Theatre on Monday, Aug. 1, 2016, in New York. (Credit: Evan Agostini/Invision/AP)

Award-winning actor Adam Beach visits Toppenish

November is Native American Heritage Month. In central Washington, different events celebrate these communities. On Friday, Nov. 22, Heritage University will host the award-winning actor Adam Beach in Toppenish His visit is closing out the university’s events recognizing the Native American communities’ contributions.

Read More »
Old homes in a denser neighborhood near Tacoma's busy Sixth Avenue.

Tacoma City Council moves forward with zoning changes

The next phase of Tacoma’s attempts to address housing shortages will soon be implemented, as the Tacoma City Council has voted unanimously to adopt the second phase of the Home in Tacoma zoning package.
The package of changes to city zoning standards aims to create more opportunities for different types of housing across the city, including by allowing more units to be developed on a standard city lot.

Read More »